Fire-toasted sugar with sea salt, vanilla, and grass-grazed milk. A perfect balance of salty and sweet.

As a teen, Jeni loved learning from the French pastry apprentices at La Chatelaine, the Columbus bakery where she worked. One chef regaled her with stories of the “salty” caramel from his hometown in Brittany. What the chef meant to say was salted caramel. But, lost in translation, Jeni interpreted his version as extra-salty, like Scandinavian licorice—saltier than standard salted caramel. So when she began making ice cream a few years later, in 1996, Jeni made a burnt sugar ice cream with vanilla and a heavypinch of sea salt. What she imagined this salty French caramel tastes like. It was an instant hit. Now considered Jeni’s signature, we still make it the same way we always have—by caramelizing sugar in a kettle over fire. It’s a dangerous method that requires a lot of precision, but it’s worth it. This is why our caramel has such a beautiful, nutty quality. Adding cream and grass-grazed milk enhances the butteriness of the caramel.


Nonfat Milk, Cream, Cane Sugar, Tapioca Syrup, Brown Sugar, Sea Salt, Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Extract. Contains: Milk. Gluten free.

Jeni's Salty Caramel Ice Cream Pint




    Gift Cards

    632 State Rd in West Tisbury


    Mon - Sat: 8 am - 6 pm 

    Sun: 8 am - 5pm 

    • Facebook
    • Instagram